I highlight earlier a letter to the editor of The New York Times today regarding a recent article that was in err with regard to the development of the constitution of the Kurdistan Region. General Jay Garner, who I’ve mentioned before and who led Operation Provide Comfort, wrote his response today.
Everyone involved has worked to maintain a transparent and open process. While we’ve been formally framing the constitution since 2006, the document itself is based upon an evolving draft that was first conceived in 1974!
In the process, we’ve consulted with all major constituencies in the Kurdistan Region, as well as international experts and democratic governments throughout the world. We’ve studied numerous existing constitutions—including those of Canada, Germany and several U.S. states. Moreover, as an addition step, we intend to print approximately 800,000 copies of the latest draft and distribute them to every household in the Region.
Now it appears that the referendum on the constitution will be delayed until later this year. This gives an opportunity for the authors of the constitution, and other members of Kurdistan’s parliament to follow up on the distribution of the constitution and go around the Region and hold town hall style meetings to discuss in greater detail the contents of the constitution with our public. It will be great to see a thorough public debate on another major milestone of Kurdistan’s.
We is an English translation available, I am unable to locate on on the KRG website.
ReplyDeleteDear Kak Qubat,
ReplyDeleteI suggest you read article number 65 of the proposed constitution before making these conclusions.
This is not the best constitution that there can be.
I am qouting article number 22, 6.1:
No law's effect can be backdated to the past "unless there is a law that states otherwise"
I am just asking you sir, what kind of constitution allows backdating of laws? This will not only ruin investment but also create never ending uncertainity!
I am not sure if any US or Canadian constitution/expert is recommending this. BTW, this is only one of the articles, if I move on I need to write an entire thesis on the problems with this constitution.
I think we should have a major re-write of this constitution then propose it on the public. The kurds can do much better than that!